水草情迷

如果要舉行一個水草造景比賽, 要點樣先可以公平呢, 由誰做評判, 評審標準又如何呢 !?
唔知 ADA 同外國的比賽, 是如何運作的呢 !? 我們又有否舉行的條件 ?!

_________________
多多交流, 多多研究, 多多搜尋
我的水族相簿

Can Fat kei boss give marks?

最大問題是,o係邊度比賽？唔通我地租個場地？如果o係番自己屋企參加,咁未要D評判上門！

我覺得參賽者會獲發no. 一個
到影相時要將個no. 一齊影埋評分
可行嗎？

至於俾份方面，如果想尊業d的話，可以大家推舉幾個公應有料子的魚友(不過唔可以參賽)。如果想大眾d的話就一人一票。當然投票資格最好係入了會某一時期的會員(香港果d投票都要起香港住左七年先得)。然後分幾次投票(唔post 名的，只被發number)

各位應為如何？

用牌仔都係一個好辨法，俾份我贊成一人一票,再分幾個分數o黎投,如技術、外觀、魚是否養得好等等。

Might also have "Tank of the Month", "Tank of the Week", "Tank of the Year". "Tank of the century", ...... Like the one in www.aquahobby.com

If for the first time trial, we can do this "simple" first. Everything on the net. I saw some other marine reef website also do the same. Posting all the photos in one area, then people (members only) just click on the photo to vote. Those who get highest vote within specific period get win.

However, one concern is for taking photos. Everybody has different level of photography, and I believe color of the leaves is very important for judgement.

Well, just my 2 cents.

I don't think posting photos on the net for the competition is a good idea. Nowadays computer software technology is so sophisticated that even a bad photo can be"touch up" to a good one. Green grass can be changed to red. Fishes can be added onto the photo. Images can be downloaded from somewhere else,etc.

May be we can take the ADA competition for reference. All entries should take a front view slide photo and a print out photo of that slide. I think this can minimize the chance of cheating.

有冇機會搞呢 ~~???

唔好不了了之啦 ~~~

_________________

記住 : Idea 要無聊 ! Outcome 要有料 !
Its better to regret sth that u done than sth u havent !

post出黎,由元老,大長老一人一票,or逐個評分
由網主實地觀察,睇下係咪"真有其缸",剔除惡作劇嘅不合理分數
就已經好夠公信力啦

如用相片作評分,讚成Sean的提議,不可用數碼相,一定要用幻燈片原件.

You can refer to
http://www.aquaticquotient.com/competition.html
an online aquascaping contest organized by Singaporean for further details. In fact, you guys are welcome to take part in this contest as well. [/url]

waw~ 幻燈片 ~~?? 用咩影 ga~~???~~~~ ~~~

_________________

記住 : Idea 要無聊 ! Outcome 要有料 !
Its better to regret sth that u done than sth u havent !

普通相機都得,包括儍瓜機.

There is an interesting point for this contest:
"Pictures thus submitted are to be in DIGITAL format........ Touchups may be done for color, sharpness and contrast. "
Will someone then MAKE his/her 紅蝴蝶 into a SUPER 紅蝴蝶?